Justin Boots Reviews

Justin Boots has an overall rating of 3.8 based on 43 reviews. Customer feedback on Justin Boots is mixed: Justin Boots reviewers highlight positive aspects like high-quality materials, comfortable fit, stylish designs, excellent customer service, which strongly appeal to outdoor enthusiasts, fashion-conscious consumers, workers needing durable footwear. However, Justin Boots is often criticized for its higher price point, limited sizing options, longer shipping times, occasional quality control issues.

3.8/5.0

43 reviews

5 Stars

10

4 Stars

2

3 Stars

6

2 Stars

4

1 Star

0

All Justin Boots Reviews (43)
David_vega01
May 18, 2026
"Nice Boots, But My Wallet Felt the Drama"
The boots are definitely good quality and they look solid, so no complaints there. But for the price, I was expecting a little more magic. They’re decent, just not quite the grand, life-changing boot experience I was hoping for.
VickieKusel
May 17, 2026
"Sharp and classic"
I don’t have a ton of context since I’ve only had them a bit, but they look really sharp and have that nice classic feel to them. Happy with them so far.
David-schiff
May 16, 2026
"Nice Looking Boots, Rough Break-In"
The boots look really good, so I was excited to wear them, but the break-in period was rough. My feet were hurting for a few days before they finally started feeling okay. I also never got any follow-up after buying them, which was kind of annoying. A quick check-in or some care/break-in tips would’ve been nice.
CharlotteRoy_58
May 13, 2026
"Felt a little like a bait and switch"
The boots looked really nice online, but once they arrived, they weren’t quite what I thought I was ordering. The color was noticeably darker in person, and the fit details didn’t really match up for me either. They’re not awful boots, but it definitely had that annoying bait-and-switch feeling when the listing makes you expect one thing and you get something different.
joannemusgrove8917
May 02, 2026
"Smooth and Fast Delivery"
Shipping was quicker than I expected, and the box showed up in great shape. My boots arrived a few days early, and the whole experience was really smooth with no issues at all.
david-Stevens
April 29, 2026
"Boots were okay, but the box was rough"
The boots themselves seem fine, but the box showed up beat up with a few dents. I know packaging isn’t everything, but it did make me feel like the order wasn’t handled with much care. Kind of disappointing, honestly.
Tim_williams70
April 29, 2026
"Super Comfortable Boots"
I got my Justin boots a few weeks ago, and I’ve gotta say, they’ve been great. I wore them for a full day at work and my feet didn’t hurt like they used to with my old pair. They broke in fast too, which was a nice surprise. The fit’s really comfortable, not too tight, and they’re easy to walk around in. I’m really happy with them
CharlesErvin_41
April 10, 2026
"Good grip for barn and shop work"
I grabbed a pair from justinboots mainly to wear around the barn and in the shop, and they’ve been solid so far. The traction is a lot better than my old boots, especially on wet concrete, which was kind of the main thing I was worried about. I’ve had them in mud and on slick steps too, and I haven’t been sliding around or anything. Sizing felt right to me as well. Overall I’m happy with them, especially since...
hello_stephanie304
March 20, 2026
"Got the boots, but the site needs work"
I did end up finding the boots I wanted, so I’ll give the site credit for that, but shopping on my phone felt more annoying than it should’ve. The filters were helpful, but some pages took a while to load, and I had to keep hitting back just to compare things, which got old fast.
Checkout was fine once I finally got there, but I really wish the size details and photos were easier to look at side by side. It’s not a terrible site, just average, and if it stays this clunky I’d probably start looking somewhere else next time.
RILEY
February 28, 2026
"My feet actually stay cool in these"
I ordered a pair from justinboots.com and the first thing I noticed, weirdly enough, was how breathable they are. Like, I expected them to be sturdy and all that, but I didn’t expect my feet to feel this comfortable after wearing them for hours. They don’t have that closed-in, too-hot boot feeling that makes you want to kick them off the second you get home.

I’ve worn them walking around quite a bit, just doing regular day-to-day stuff, and they’ve stayed comfortable the whole time. No sweaty feet, no gross end-of-day feeling, just solid boots that I actually want to keep wearing. Easy 5 stars from me, and yeah, I’d definitely buy them again.
AlmaWilliams
February 25, 2026
"Quick checkout and no surprises"
I ordered a pair of boots the whole checkout process was easy. I’m always a little nervous about getting fooled by hidden fees or weird charges at the last second, but the total was clearly shown before I paid, which made me feel better. Everything loaded fast, the order went through without any issues, and I got the confirmation email right away. Overall, it was smooth and I don’t really have any complaints.
MabelSimson_05
February 21, 2026
"Good boots, but sizing and stock were frustrating"
I’ve always liked Justin boots, and the website is easy to use, but this was kind of annoying. So many of the styles I wanted weren’t available in my size, and I kept checking back like they’d magically be restocked. I feel a little stupid for trusting it would work out, because it was mostly just a waste of time. I’d probably still shop here again, but they really need to do better with availability.
christine1975
February 15, 2026
"Fit Was Just Off"
I ordered my usual size since that’s what I wear in most boots, and my first reaction was, “Well, this is weird.” The toe area felt way too tight, but the heel was somehow loose at the same time. I only walked around the house for a bit before getting annoyed. I even checked the size chart, so I’m not really sure what went wrong. The quality seemed fine, but the fit was a hard no for me, and dealing with a return or exchange felt like more trouble than it was worth.
jamesbrowne0751
February 08, 2026
"I really like the way these boots look…"
I really like the way these boots look, and the leather does feel sturdy and decent quality. But the arch support was kind of a letdown. After wearing them for a few hours, my feet were already tired, which was frustrating because I wasn’t expecting to stress about comfort right away. They’re not the worst boots I’ve owned, but for the price, I definitely expected them to feel better. I’ll probably end up buying insoles just to make them wearable for longer
david-Devilbiss
January 21, 2026
"Nice looking boots, but disappointing"
The boots look really good right out of the box. Sharp. But after wearing them for a short time, the stitching already started coming apart. Disappointing. I wanted to like them, but the quality just didn’t hold up
CHESLEY
January 18, 2026
"Takes About 2 Seconds to Put On"
These slip on super easily and come off just as fast, probably in like 2 seconds. Really convenient when I’m in a hurry
tess.Lyall
December 30, 2025
"Solid Boots So Far"
I got these boots last month, i’m happy with them so far. I was a little cautious at first because I’ve been burned before with leather boots that look good online but feel cheap in person, so I kept the box and receipt just in case. But the leather feels thick without being overly stiff, they’re already breaking in nicely, and they have that real leather smell. So far, no regrets
Lynnette_barrette88
December 30, 2025
"Return went fine, but the wait was annoying"
I had to return a pair of boots, and while customer support was actually helpful once they got to me, the waiting part was frustrating. It took longer than I expected to get things moving, but in the end they handled the return well.
MaggieRose_56
December 22, 2025
"Toe cap didn’t really hold up"
I bought these for working in the shop, and they were decent at first. The boots are comfortable overall, but the protective toe feels kind of thin to me. After one hard hit, it actually dented, which makes me wonder if the toe cap just isn’t as sturdy as it should be, or maybe I just got a weaker pair. Either way, I don’t really trust them for serious shop work anymore.
SaraAlva
December 20, 2025
"I grabbed a pair of Justin waterproof..."
I grabbed a pair of Justin waterproof boots from justinboots.com, and they’ve been really solid so far. I wore them through wet grass, mud, and some rain at work, and my socks stayed dry the whole day, which is exactly what I needed. They did take a little breaking in, though somehow they felt comfortable and stiff at the same time, if that makes sense. I wouldn’t say they’re the best boots I’ve ever owned, but I’m also happy with them and would probably buy them again.

View More Reviews

Have a question about Justin Boots?

Customer Reviews

Ask a Question

Welcome to WorthEPenny.com! We use cookies to better understand your preferences, optimize our website and services, enhance user experiences, personalize content and ads, and provide social media and other third-party features. If you want to learn more about cookies and why we use them, visit our Cookie Policy page.